To be eligible for the Hall of Fame, a player must have a minimum of 2,000 career plate appearances, 1,000 career innings pitched, or 250 career pitching appearances. Players are listed by year elected, and are elected at the position they played for most of their career, with the team they spent the most seasons with. An asterisk denotes players elected on their first year of eligibility.
|1960||1B||Felipe GonzalezF Gonzalez||Texas A&M AggiesTexas A&M Aggies||4 (1955–1958)||.380-228-718, 21 SB, 1.134 OPS||4xMVP, RotY, 4xAS|
|1960||CF||Alan RoyallA Royall||Miami HurricanesMiami Hurricanes||4 (1952–1955)||.342-218-546, 26 SB, 1.110 OPS||3xMVP, RotY, 3xAS|
|1966||P||Lance GarciaL Garcia||Texas A&M AggiesTexas A&M Aggies||4 (1961–1964)||113–20, 824 SO, 1.89 ERA||2xCYA, RotY, 4xAS|
|1968||P||Cornelius BurnsC Burns||Texas A&M AggiesTexas A&M Aggies||4 (1957–1960)||101–33, 866 SO, 2.49 ERA||2xCYA, RotY, 4xAS|
|1970||C||Michael HigginbothamM Higginbotham||Arkansas RazorbacksArkansas Razorbacks||3 (1963–1965)||.361-196-509, 4 SB, 1.150 OPS||3xMVP, RotY, 3xAS|
|1975||P||James GoreJ Gore||Michigan State SpartansMichigan State Spartans||4 (1970–1973)||121–20, 1,190 SO, 2.26 ERA||4xCYA, RotY, 4xAS|
|1987||P||Michael MatthewsM Matthews||Minnesota GophersMinnesota Gophers||4 (1975–1978)||81–28, 918 SO, 1.91 ERA||3xCYA, RotY, 4xAS|